The perceptions and experiences of people injured in motor vehicle crashes in a compensation scheme setting: a qualitative study

Murgatroyd, Darnel; Lockwood, Keri; Garth, Belinda; Cameron, Ian D.
May 2015
BMC Public Health;2015, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Background: The evidence that compensation related factors are associated with poor recovery is substantial but these measures are generic and do not consider the complexity of scheme design. The objectives of this study were to understand people's perceptions and experiences of the claims process after sustaining a compensable injury in a motor vehicle crash (including why people seek legal representation); and to explore ways to assist people following a compensable injury and improve their experience with the claims process. Methods: A qualitative study in a Compulsory Third Party (CTP) personal injury scheme covering the state of New South Wales (NSW), Australia. A series of five focus groups, with a total of 32 participants who had sustained mild to moderate injuries in a motor vehicle crash, were conducted from May to June 2011 with four to eight attendees in each group. These were audio-recorded and transcribed. The methodology was based on a grounded theory approach using thematic analysis and constant comparison to generate coding categories for themes. Data saturation was reached. Analyst triangulation was used to ensure credibility of the results. Results: Five primary themes were identified: complexity of the claims process; requirement of legal representation; injury recovery expectations; importance of timely healthcare decision making; and improvements for injury recovery. Some participants struggled, finding the claims process stressful and subsequently sought legal advice; whilst others reported a straight forward recovery, helpful insurer interactions and no legal representation. Most participants were influenced by injury recovery expectations, and timely healthcare decision making. To assist with injury recovery, access to objective information about the claims process using online technology and social media was considered paramount. Conclusions: Participants had contrasting injury recovery experiences and their perceptions of the claims process differed and were influenced by injury recovery expectations, and timeliness of healthcare decision making. Improvements to the claims process are required, including: simplification or streamlining (possibly using online technology and/or social media to reduce paperwork); and providing access to objective information. There is a need to trial early interventions and new claims management policies that could improve injury recovery and satisfaction with the claims process.


Related Articles

  • The Next Thing I Knew. Stewart, David // Washingtonian Magazine;Mar2006, Vol. 41 Issue 6, p171 

    Relates the experience of a man who was hit by a car at Wisconsin Avenue in Washington, D.C. Physical injuries sustained by the man from the accident; Composition of a story about the accident; Cost of damages paid to the victim.

  • General Motors Ordered To Pay $4.9 Billion To Six People Burned In Collision.  // Jet;07/26/99, Vol. 96 Issue 8, p10 

    Focuses on the biggest personal injury award in United States history in which a jury ordered General Motors Corp. (GM) to pay $4.9 billion to six people burned after crashes in their Chevrolet Malibu automobile.

  • Multiple holding: A model for supervision in the context of trauma and abuse. Virtue, Claire; Fouché, Christa // Aotearoa New Zealand Social Work Review;Oct2009-Jan2010, Vol. 21/22 Issue 4/1, p64 

    This paper reports on a grounded theory study involving eight practitioners; four supervisees and four supervisors took part in individual interviews and two separate focus groups. The core finding of the research is that multiple holding is needed to provide adequate support for professionals...

  • No chance. Farrell, Liam // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);4/8/95, Vol. 310 Issue 6984, p945 

    Accounts author's experience of attending to a family who has been traffic accident victims in Ireland. Incidence of deaths due to traffic accidents; Being called to an emergency; Interventions following a triage; Resuscitating a newborn who was delivered during the accident.

  • Cutting the toll.  // Automotive News;9/9/1996, Vol. 71 Issue 5677, p27 

    Presents information on automobile fatality rate in the United States, from 1966 to 1995.

  • Genetics Casebook. Day-Salvatore, Debra; Pellegrino, Joan E; White, Mary; Fisher, Allan J; Anwar, Mujahid; Krasna, Irwin H // Journal of Perinatology;Jan1999, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p72 

    Presents a case report of a 27-year-old Italian woman, gravida 2, para 0-0-1-0, who was referred to the antenatal testing unit at 29 weeks gestation after a motor vehicle accident. Result of the ultrasound examination done after the accident; Reasons why the labor was induced at 35 weeks and 5...

  • Motor vehicle crash fatalities: The effects of race and maritial status. Kposowa, Augustine J.; Adams, Michelle // Applied Behavioral Science Review;1998, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p69 

    Presents a study that compares death due to natural causes with victims of motor fatalities. Hypothesis that the race and marital status of victims would affect the possibility of death from a motor vehicle accident; Analysis of cross-sectional data of all deaths occurring in the United States...

  • Catholics demand justice after U.S. armored car kills girls. Donovan, Gill // National Catholic Reporter;9/13/2002, Vol. 38 Issue 39, p10 

    Presents information on the apology demanded by Catholics for the death of two girls killed by a U.S. military vehicle in South Korea. Place of accident; Particulars of the deceased girls.

  • No sweet repeat award.  // Long Island Business News (7/1993 to 5/2009);10/14/96, Vol. 43 Issue 42, p1 

    Reports on 1995 traffic related fatalities in New York State according to the Department of Motor Vehicles. Suffolk County as having the highest number of fatalities; Nassau County ranking.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics