Surgical vs Nonsurgical Treatment of Adults With Displaced Fractures of the Proximal Humerus

Rangan, Amar; Handoll, Helen; Brealey, Stephen; Jefferson, Laura; Keding, Ada; Martin, Belen Corbacho; Goodchild, Lorna; Ling-Hsiang Chuang; Hewitt, Catherine; Torgerson, David
March 2015
JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;3/10/2015, Vol. 313 Issue 10, p1037
Academic Journal
IMPORTANCE. The need for surgery for the majority of patients with displaced proximal humeral fractures is unclear, but its use is increasing. OBJECTIVE. To evaluate the clinical effectiveness o f surgical vs nonsurgical treatment for adults with displaced fractures of the proximal humerus involving the surgical neck. DESIGN, SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS. A pragmatic, multicenter, parallel-group, randomized clinical trial, the Proximal Fracture of the Humerus Evaluation by Randomization (PROFHER) trial, recruited 250 patients aged 16 years or older (mean age, 66 years [range, 24-92 years]; 192 [77%] were female,- and 249 [99.6% ] were white) who presented at the orthopedic departments of 32 acute UK National Health Service hospitals between September 2008 and April 2011 within 3 weeks after sustaining a displaced fracture of the proximal humerus involving the surgical neck. Patients were followed up for 2 years (up to April 2013) and 215 had complete follow-up data. The data for 231 patients (114 in surgical group and 117 in nonsurgical group) were included in the primary analysis. INTERVENTIONS. Fracture fixation or humeral head replacement were performed by surgeons experienced in these techniques. Nonsurgical treatment was sling immobilization. Standardized outpatient and community-based rehabilitation was provided to both groups. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES. Primary outcome was the Oxford Shoulder Score (range, 0-48; higher scores indicate better outcomes) assessed during a 2-year period, with assessment and data collection at 6,12, and 24 months. Sample size was based on a minimal clinically important difference of 5 points for the Oxford Shoulder Score. Secondary outcomes were the Short-Form 12 (SF-12), complications, subsequent therapy, and mortality. RESULTS. There was no significant mean treatment group difference in the Oxford Shoulder Score averaged over 2 years (39.07 points for the surgical group vs 38.32 points for the nonsurgical group; difference of 0.75 points [95% Cl, -1.33 to 2.84 points]; P = .48) or at individual time points. There were also no significant between-group differences over 2 years in the mean SF-12 physical component score (surgical group: 1.77 points higher [95% Cl, -0 .8 4 to 4.39 points]; P = .18); the mean SF-12 mental component score (surgical group: 1.28 points lower [95% Cl, -3.80 to 1.23 points]; P = .32); complications related to surgery or shoulder fracture (30 patients in surgical group vs 23 patients in nonsurgical group; P = .28), requiring secondary surgery to the shoulder (11 patients in both groups), and increased or new shoulder-related therapy (7 patients vs 4 patients, respectively; P = .58); and mortality (9 patients vs 5 patients; P = .27). Ten medical complications (2 cardiovascular events, 2 respiratory events, 2 gastrointestinal events, and 4 others) occurred in the surgical group during the postoperative hospital stay. CONCLUSIONS and RELEVANCE. Among patients with displaced proximal humeral fractures involving the surgical neck, there was no significant difference between surgical treatment compared with nonsurgical treatment in patient-reported clinical outcomes over 2 years following fracture occurrence. These results do not support the trend of increased surgery for patients with displaced fractures of the proximal humerus. TRIAL REGISTRATION. isrctn.com Identifier: ISRCTN50850043


Related Articles

  • Thrombospondin-2 Influences the Proportion of Cartilage and Bone During Fracture Healing. Taylor, Douglas K.; Meganck, Jeffrey A.; Terkhorn, Shawn; Rajani, Rajiv; Naik, Amish; O'Keefe, Regis J.; Goldstein, Steven A.; Hankenson, Kurt D. // Journal of Bone & Mineral Research;Jun2009, Vol. 24 Issue 6, p1043 

    The article reports on the results of research which was conducted in an effort to determine the impact thromospondin2 had on the proportion of cartilage and bone in fracture healing in mice. Researchers found that the use of thrombospondin-2 could be used as an alternative strategy for...

  • Bilateral luxatio erecta humeri with a unilateral brachial plexus injury. Ellanti, Prasad; Davarinos, Nikolaos; Connolly, Mary J.; Khan, Hamid A. // Journal of Emergencies, Trauma & Shock;Oct-Dec2013, Vol. 6 Issue 4, p308 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article regarding the luxatio erecta humeri associated with injury on brachial plexus in the 2013 issue.

  • Distale Humerusfrakturen beim Kind. Schneidmueller, D.; Boettger, M.; Laurer, H.; Gutsfeld, P.; Bühren, V. // Der Orthopäde;Nov2013, Vol. 42 Issue 11, p977 

    Fractures of the distal humerus belong to the most common injuries of the upper arm in childhood. Most frequently occurring is the supracondylar fracture of the distal humerus. In these cases and in the second most common epicondylar fractures, the metaphysis is affected and these fractures are...

  • Cochrane in CORR: Interventions for Treating Proximal Humeral Fractures in Adults (Review). Kleinlugtenbelt, Ydo; Bhandari, Mohit // Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research;Sep2015, Vol. 473 Issue 9, p2750 

    The article discusses the study "Interventions for treating proximal humeral fractures in adults" by Helen H. G. Handoll, Benjamin J. Ollivere and Katie E. Rollins, published in "Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews," 2012, Issue 12. Topics covered include comparisons of surgical versus...

  • Risk factors associated with the occurrence of proximal humerus fractures in patients with rheumatoid arthritis: a custom strategy for preventing proximal humerus fractures. Ochi, Kensuke; Furuya, Takefumi; Ishibashi, Mina; Watanabe, Makiko; Ikari, Katsunori; Taniguchi, Atsuo; Yamanaka, Hisashi; Momohara, Shigeki // Rheumatology International;Feb2016, Vol. 36 Issue 2, p213 

    To our knowledge, no prior report focused on the risk factors for proximal humerus fractures in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the association between potential risk factors and the occurrence of proximal humerus fractures in patients with...

  • Fixing `dancer's fracture'. Hoffman, Douglas G. // Physician & Sportsmedicine;Aug96, Vol. 24 Issue 8, p36j 

    Comments on the findings from a study on professional ballet dancers can help physicians treat fractures of the distal shaft of the fifth metatarsal known as the `dancer's fracture' by M. J. O'Malley, W. G. Hamilton, et al. Management of majority of the fractures nonoperatively; Insight into...

  • Erratum.  // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Apr2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 4, p938 

    A correction to the article "Humoral Factors Enhance Fracture-Healing and Callus Formation in Patients With Traumatic Brain Injury" by Dieter Cadosch in a previous issue.

  • The elements of fracture fixation. Holz, Ulrich // Indian Journal of Orthopaedics;Nov/Dec2015, Vol. 49 Issue 6, p682 

    No abstract available.

  • Inter- and intra-observer reliability of the Baumann angle of the humerus in children with supracondylar humeral fractures. Silva, Mauricio; Pandarinath, Rajeev; Farng, Eugene; Park, Samuel; Caneda, Cherlyn; Fong, Yi-Jen; Penman, Adam // International Orthopaedics;Apr2010, Vol. 34 Issue 4, p553 

    The Baumann angle of the humerus has been commonly used as an outcome measure for supracondylar fractures in children. However, there is limited or no information about the reliability of this measurement. The purpose of this study was to determine the inter-observer reliability (IEOR) and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics