TITLE

Embracing Uncertainty, Complexity, and Change: An Eco-pragmatic Reinvention of a First-Generation Environmental Law

AUTHOR(S)
Angelo, Mary Jane
PUB. DATE
February 2006
SOURCE
Ecology Law Quarterly;2006, Vol. 33 Issue 1, p105
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Abstract
ABSTRACT
Recent scientific reports demonstrate that despite more than thirty years of environmental regulation, bird and wildlife species as well as ecosystem services, are in unprecedented decline. Pesticides are at least in part to blame for these profound declines. U.S. pesticide law has failed to carry out its mission of environmental protection. A number of recently-filed lawsuits assert that the registration of certain pesticides violates the federal Endangered Species Act. One of the great ironies of environmental law is that the ecological consequences of pesticide use, which fueled the environmental movement of the late 1960s and early 1970s, largely have been ignored for the past thirty years. Only recently has interest renewed in the ecological (as opposed to human health) risks posed by pesticides. Moreover, the explosion of pesticidal--genetically modified organism (GMO) use in agriculture raises concerns regarding the novel risks to biodiversity posed by these new pesticides. Surprisingly, however, the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) has not changed significantly with regard to ecological matters since 1972 and remains primarily a consumer protection statute not well-suited for ecological protection. The Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) implementation of FIFRA has not kept pace with our developing understanding of the uncertainty, complexity, and changing nature of ecological systems. This Article breaks new ground by being the first to use the new legal discipline of "coo-pragmatism" to analyze, and then reinvent, U.S. pesticide law to better protect ecological resources. For years, environmental legal scholars have sought a middle ground between absolutist risk-based approaches to environmental regulation and cost/benefit analysis approaches. In the past several years, scholars have begun exploring the emerging field of eco-pragmatism--a dramatic new framework for environmental decision-making developed by Professor Daniel Farber--to achieve a workable middle ground. Although a number of prominent legal scholars have analyzed eco-pragmatism in a general sense, none have applied an eco-pragmatic framework to any environmental pollution control law. This Article is the first to do so. This Article builds on Farber's work and others by first bolstering eco-pragmatism through consciously incorporating principles of ecological science and then applying the strengthened eco-pragmatism to a long-overlooked area, pesticide law. As the first application of eco-pragmatism to a field of environmental pollution control law, this Article is an important step in the development of this area of legal theory. By analyzing current pesticide law as well as EPA's implementation of such law through an eco-pragmatic lens, this Article identifies areas of the law in need of revision and proposes revisions based on eco-pragmatic principles, which it" implemented would greatly enhance our ability to protect critical ecological resources.
ACCESSION #
21294712

 

Related Articles

  • Developing Effective Compliance Assistance Activities and Programs for Small Businesses in India and the United States. Kakade, Seema M. // Environmental Law Reporter: News & Analysis;May2005, Vol. 35 Issue 5, p10341 

    This article focuses on environmental compliance assistance activities and programs in India and the United States. Despite the vastly differing perceptions of environmental compliance in the United States and India, both countries share a surprisingly similar system for managing and regulating...

  • SMOG BUSTERS.  // State Legislatures;Feb2006, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p10 

    The article deals with the legislation adopted by the California Air Resources Board that bars cruise ships from burning refuse within three miles of shore in February 2006. Reducing pollution caused by burning trash, ranging from food to rags, will reduce cancer risks and could save as many as...

  • ENVIRONMENTAL LAW AND NATIONAL SECURITY: CAN EXISTING EXEMPTIONS IN ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS PRESERVE DOD TRAINING AND OPERATIONAL PREROGATIVES WITHOUT NEW LEGISLATION? Willard, E. G.; Zimmerman, Tom; Bee, Eric // Air Force Law Review;2004, Vol. 54, p65 

    Describes the existing national security exemptions in environmental laws in the U.S. and examples of their use. Regulatory requirements for biannual inventories of hazardous wastes generated; Concerns for national security at Department of Defense facilities; Presidential exemption for Clean...

  • CASE LAW.  // Environmental Law Review;2004, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p56 

    Reports on cases involving environmental law in Europe and Great Britain from September 11, 2003 to December 11, 2003. European Commission's claim that the Netherlands failed to fulfil its obligations concerning the protection waters against pollution; Commission's claim that Great Britain...

  • Pollution Prevention and Control (England and Wales) Regulations 2000. Stranks, Jeremy // A-Z of the Environment;2008, p318 

    Information about the "Pollution Prevention and Control Regulations 2000" is presented. It states that the said regulations are made under the Pollution Prevention and Control Act 1999 and set out a Pollution Control Regime for the purpose of implementing the Integrated Pollution Prevention and...

  • Emergency Response and Planning Requirements Applicable to Unpermitted Air Pollution Releases. Reitze, Jr., Arnold W. // Brigham Young University Law Review;2005, Vol. 2005 Issue 5, p1075 

    The article presents information on the federal environmental laws dealing with unpermitted air pollution releases. Environmental law, as it has evolved over the past thirty-five years, is generally focused at those who routinely dispose of wastes to the air, land, and water. Nonroutine...

  • Pollution fines 'too low to discourage firms'  // Professional Engineering;8/13/2003, Vol. 16 Issue 14, p14 

    Reports on how the pollution fines for Britain's air and waterways are considered as too low to discourage big businesses from the act of pollution. Publication of the Environment Agency's annual Spotlight on Business Environment Performance report for 2002 as the warning signal; How some...

  • REGULATORY UPDATE: FQPA CANADIAN STYLE.  // Grounds Maintenance;Jun2000, Vol. 35 Issue 6, p1 

    Reports on the Canadian House of Commons Environment Committee's May 2000 issuance of a report on the use of pesticides. Suggestion that homeowners accept the presence of dandelions; Acceptance of diversity as an integral part of a health environment; Call for the government to develop a...

  • MOEP Collects Advice oil Pesticides Project Standard.  // China Chemical Reporter;4/16/2009 Petrochemical Supplement, Vol. 20 Issue 11A, p12 

    The article reports on a new technical standard on environmental impact assessment for pesticide construction project compiled by the Ministry of Environmental Protection (MOEP) in China. It relates that the standard is guidelines for domestic pesticide makers to develop safe, high potency, low...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics